CR Blog
Why does everybody shoot work like this?
Posted by Patrick Burgoyne, 15 December 2006, 21:29 Permalink Comments (4)
This rather nice set of posters (featured on Computer Love) is by German designer Michalt Slawek. All very lovely, but they left me wondering one thing: Why is it that this has become the default way to photograph graphic design work?
At Creative Review, we used to get sent work that had been beautifully photographed on white backgrounds, all ready to be cut out if necessary. Then when digital technology really took off, everyone got very excited, and a bit lazy, and started sending us flat, original artwork files. Not as nice, but much cheaper.
But in the last year or so, the images that arrive at our palatial headquarters in the heart of London's bustling West End have started to feature a procession of headless standing figures. Arms outstretched, they nip the work gingerly between finger and thumb. Who are they? Is it the same person each time – some kind of professional poster holder-upper who, seizing their chance, has carved out an unlikely career in the graphic display business?
I can see the advantages of doing it this way. We'd far rather feature images of physical objects than Illustrator files any day – the latter being so anaemic and, obviously, one-dimensional. With these images you get a sense of scale and a feel for the quality of whatever print finishes have been used. And if you could see the face of the holder-upper, well, I guess it might detract from the work.
What we'd really like to know is: who thought of it first?
4 Comments
Patrick, the answer may lie somewhere around the year 2000 with Emigre 54.
Hard to tell on the web site, but white-gloved hands hold over 250 pieces of graphic design. Disconcerting to amusing effect.
2006-12-15 22:01:58
Ah I see it isn't just me who notices this.
But have those posters actually been printed and photographed, or simply photoshopped? They look a bit too clean and crisp (especially the last two posters), or is it just me...
-
2006-12-16 03:39:23
I believe Patrick has it correct. That Emigre issue definitely set an impression on many designers with pages upon pages of a white gloved person holding and displaying designed articles.
2006-12-16 22:41:11
Whenever I see work presented this way I think to myself: Ew. (One rather...self-imbued designer I know is always sure to include the bottom half of his face, complete with a smug little smile, in the image. Ew.) I've always thought that people choose to present work this way (a) to give a sense of scale and (b) to show that it has actually been produced. There's also perhaps some pride of authorship there.
If I were ever to present my work this way, I would do it the way Cornel Windlin did it with his Public Affairs poster: shoot the pressman, holding it sideways.
2007-01-15 20:51:41
| Range Rover v Hadron Collider (5) |
| Romain Gavras directs promo for M.I.A.'s Bad Girls (8) |
| D&AD 50: Pregnant Man, 1970 (4) |
| Young animators light up BT Tower (1) |
| The type will set you free (5) |
| Farrow designs Format for PSB |
| VW: The Dog Strikes Back |
| BBC unveils redesigned Sport site |
| The £25 logo |
| Matthew Broderick's day off |
| Advertising | (1031) | |
| Art | (385) | |
| Books | (248) | |
| Digital | (406) | |
| Graphic Design | (1115) | |
| Illustration | (622) | |
| Magazine / Newspaper | (195) | |
| Music Video / Film | (705) | |
| Photography | (354) | |
| Type / Typography | (246) |

