CR Blog

The Designer's Review of Books

Digital, Graphic Design, Music Video / Film, Photography

Posted by Mark Sinclair, 16 December 2008, 12:45    Permalink    Comments (2)

Designer, academic and writer Andy Polaine has set up The Designer's Review of Books, a blog dedicated solely to examining both the content and production values of some of the design publications vying for your attention (and hard earned cash)...

"I started The Designer's Review of Books for a few reasons," says Polaine. "I’d been thinking of a decent niche website/blog idea that would extend my design journalism and, whilst I was trying to research something online, I noticed that there wasn’t really a website dedicated to design book reviews."

Also, Polaine is based in Offenburg, a small town in Germany, and so conducts much of his design and teaching work remotely. While the benefits of moving out of the city are numerous, one problem he found was the lack of nearby bookshops geared towards creative titles.

"Amazon makes it easy to shop online," he says, "but a lot of the reviews are unreliable, or you have no idea who the person is doing the review." In response to this, he hopes that his critical take on design books will become a trusted resource for the creative industry.

"Design books are a mixed bag," he says. "Some look great but the text is really shabby (I have a review of one such book coming up soon). Others promise a lot and are terribly produced. And there are some books that designers should read that are not strictly design books. It depends on the book, but sometimes it's about the book as an object in its own right, and that is hard to judge online.

"I try and write about the production values of the book as well as the content so that others who are in my position – and there must be many – can take a punt on buying a book they have never had in their hands."

Polaine also plans to post guest reviews by designers and possibly include some author interviews further down the line.

“It seems like a dream to have a stack of design books on your desk until you have to read them all and write reviews (and photograph them),” he says. “I read the books thoroughly rather than just skimming through, otherwise it's pointless. But that takes a lot of time.

"It is a labour of love at the moment, so of course, I also hope design firms and publishers will want to advertise on the DRB so I can keep it going.”

Check out Polaine's first few posts at designersreviewofbooks.com.

2 Comments

The notion of one person setting himself up as the sole or primary arbiter of new design books could only sound like a bold new step forward to a reader who relies entirely on online browsing for information about design books.

Eye magazine, for one, has published a substantial reviews section since 1990. Every issue many new design books are reviewed by a wide team of contributors, giving the range of perspectives that book reviewing actually requires. The longest of these reviews can run to 1,000 words or more. Other publications such as CR, Baseline, Blueprint, Grafik and Print in the United States also carry substantial graphic design book reviews.

It's nice to see Andy Polaine's venture but, really, there is no lack of good advice out there already about the latest books. If you believe in print, then support it.
Bibliophile
2009-03-04 08:52:28


Bibliophile - As you may have seen - it's not just me that does the reviews.

In any case, why would a consistent viewpoint be any worse than "range of perspectives that book reviewing actually requires"? On what are you basing that claim? Film reviews, for example, are often a single person or two people offering reviews over many years.

The length of the reviews is also comparable in many cases, but that is also not necessarily a sign of competency. It's quite possible to offer an articulate review in 500 words.

Your arguments don't really stand up to much scrutiny, in my view.

I enjoy the reviews on some of the other sites you mentioned. I have written one for some of them too. The aim of The Designer's Review of Books was to provide a place that focusses on that alone and isn't a more general design or design criticism site like the ones you mentioned. It is intended to be more niche and that has always been clear.
Andy Polaine
2009-03-10 10:04:42


Tell us what you think

What happens with my feedback?

We no longer require you to register and have a password in order to comment, simply fill in the form below. All comments are moderated so you may experience a short delay before your comment appears. CR encourages comments to be short and to the point. As a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.

Share This — Social Bookmarking

Get the RSS Feed