CR Blog

Kyoorius Design Yatra Days 2&3

Posted by Patrick Burgoyne, 16 September 2008, 12:22    Permalink    Comments (12)

erik-kessels-by-inge-schout.jpg
Warning: Do not believe everything this man says. Erik Kessels by Inge Schout

This year's Kyoorius Design Yatra came to a conclusion here in Goa yesterday with some inspiring words about sustainability, and a hint of controversy, Plus, why Erik Kessels is a big fat fibber...

Day 2 of the conference kicked off with a predictably great talk from Pentagram NY's Paula Scher. "My work has a narrow framework: I don't have much talent, so I stretch it as far as it will go," she said with admirable self-effacement. She talked about growing up thinking of Helvetica and the International Style as The Enemy - the manifestation of the establishment which, at the time equated to the Vietnam War. Perhaps that's what happens when you grow up a designer - typefaces take on geopolitical significance.

Running through her greatest hits - both commercial and personal - Scher explained that she designed her famous Citibank logo (original sketch on napkin, below) "in two hours" but what she was really paid for was "to go to the meetings for a year and a half to get the logo sold".

original-citi-logo.jpg

Aside from the golden oldies, Commissioner Scher (for she actually holds the post in NY City and advises on planning issues) revealed a new project for Pittsburgh. The city is, apparently, cut in two by a motorway. People on one side of the divide don't want to visit the downtown area on the other side because it involves going through a series of forbidding underpasses. The city wanted Scher to design them a new logo - as if that would solve anything. Instead, along with her client The Children's Museum, she has convinced them to install a series of art pieces in the underpasses that will be called The Charm Bracelet. "The concept is to connect destinations -- among them, the Children's Museum, Andy Warhol Museum, Carnegie Science Center, National Aviary, Mattress Factory, New Hazlett Theater, Allegheny Commons park and sports stadiums -- in a way that positions the North Side as the city's "family district," just as Downtown's theaters and galleries are grouped as the Cultural District," reported the local paper when the idea was presented earlier this year (see story here and image below).

pittsburgh.jpg

Asked about how she feels about the contrast between working four days a week for commercial clients and major brands like Tiffany and the rest on her paintings, Scher said "I don't have anything against people going to the bank or buying jewellery. I'm a fan of commerce, I just want conscience attached to it. And there's nobody more dishonest than my art dealer."

Next up was Kenya Hara from Japan. Exquisite work followed as Hara discussed his idea of "haptic" design that "makes all the sense drool".

She showed a series of pieces commissioned for an exhibition that he organised to explain the Haptic Design notion, including...

kiwijuicebox.jpg
Kiwi juice box (real kiwi second left) by Naoto Fukasawa

panasonic.jpg
Gel Remote Control by Panasonic Design Center - floppy when not in use, stiffens when you pick it up (ahem)

pachinko.jpg
Water Pachinko by Hara himself - a Pachinko (Japanese pinball) machine made of treated paper in drops of water trickle down an inclined surface and score points by dropping into various holes.

Hara also showed his work for Muji where he is in charge of art direction and communication. Ads like these

01.jpg

03.jpg

illustrate Muji's concept of emptiness - "Muji ads are empy vessels to be filled with your thoughts," said Hara.

One of the recurring themes in the conference - particularly in questions from the audience and discussions in the breaks - was the notion of an "Indian design" aesthetic - what is it? Does such a concept make any sense in a country as diverse as India? The presentations from Scher and Hara suggested, to me at least, a model for Indian designers. Here were two people whose work is utterly rooted in their locality, cultural traditions and personal experiences. Unwittingly or not, Scher's work speaks of New York - it's bold and strong, energetic and, at times, strident. Hara's work is subtle and beautiful, understated and elegant, like so much in Japan. Neither is overtly American or Japanese, but are nevertheless embedded in their respective cultures. Hara talked of 1000 years of Japanese culture informing his work but it is unarguably modern and of the now. Here, it seems could be a model for India, whose cultural traditions are every bit as rich as those of Japan. An aesthetic that allows for the expression of personal, local experience without resorting to the visual language of the airport gift shop.

The final day kicked off with wonderful work from Tirso Francés of Dietwee in Utrecht.

A particular personal favourite was a project for Utrecht to celebrate the upcoming 300th anniversary of the treaty named after the city that ended the wars of Spanish Succession. In a reference to the treaty's signatories, Dietwee created a simple shield device to be carried across a wide variety of uses, tying myriad activities together.

0vvu_wapens.jpg

2vvu_persmap.jpg

6vvu_posters2.jpg

Next someone - finally - talked about sustainability. Up until that point, the presentations had largely focused on the commercial role of design without discussing its ability to communicate important issues such as climate change and it's own complicity in the disaster. Harsh Purohit of Cognito Advertising gave a powerful and persuasive presentation on why Indian designers need to confront this issue - both for themselves and on behalf of their clients. "This is an opportunity for the Indian design community in the same way that Y2K was for the Indian IT industry," he argued. "The East is where living in harmony with the environment is inherent. We possess this knowledge."

"Imagine, he said, "if everything you produced - all the brochures and packaging - came back to you for you to dispose of." Such a responsibility might make designers think twice about their choices.

He was followed by another leading Indian designer, Rajesh Dahiya of CoDesign in Delhi. And controversy followed. In the course of a wide-ranging presentation of interative and identity work, Dahiya talked about an interactive installation for Titan watches (below)

titan.jpg

At one point, he mildly dissed the watches themselves. Unfortunately, people from Titan were in the audience and weren't too pleased, complaining not just to Dahiya but also to the organisers. In the end, Dahiya had to stand up and make a public apology - just before my presentation as it happens, which kind of took the mood down a tad. Tough act to follow.

Leaving aside the rows, Dahiya showed some strong work underlining his studio's position as one of the country's finest, including

chimes.jpg
Signage for Chimes Group

sig.jpg
Bag for Signature pen shops

nid.jpg
Prospectus for National Insitute of Design

Next up was Erik Kessels of Kessels Kramer whose wonderfully humorous ad work and endlessly intriguing photography publishing projects went down a storm with the audience.

The Hans Brinker work stands up incredibly well but I have to admit here that I'm somewhat miffed with Kessels. We have been the victim of a hoax. He lied to CR, the cad. A few years ago, the Hans Brinker wanted to run ad an in the UK but, because it showed a used condom, no-one would run it. Kessels told us that KK was no longer going to work for the hotel - they'd had a row and the relationship was over. Brinker confirmed this so we ran a story about what a great campaign it had been, what a shame it was ending, blah blah. It was all a lie. A stunt. Just to get some PR for Brinker. The swine.

So I'm not going to show any of his work here. So there.

And then it was my turn to wrap up. What did I learn from the three days? That, as above, the likes of Scher and Hara prove that you can invest your work with some sense of where you come from without descending into kitsch or being overtly about a geographical location. That climate change has become a communications issue - the science is there, but still people don't believe it. And that designers have, thanks to technology, never had as many options as they do now. It was, I hoped, an exciting time to be a designer, particularly one in India where there are so many opportunities to participate in the growth of a hugely significant and - hopefully - sustainable and equitable new economic power.

12 Comments

I was around at the design yatra and in several occasion I felt that we pay too much impotance to our curries!
Anyhow I hope the next year we'll have more to cheer about as far as indian design is concerned... and will look forward to hear from you as well.
Cheers
Antara
Antara
2008-09-17 07:52:19


Design yatra, this year was a turning point for the indian design industry, every one present there has at some point realised the urgent need to stop aping what has already been done in the west and to carve out an identity for indian design by putting in a little more thought than just ctrl + c, ctrl + v. wally olins certainly was very impressive...kenya hara, kessel truly inspiring...
jeetu kapadia
2008-09-17 12:32:34


Disappointed that an Indian design conference, held in India, has so few Indian designers presenting. Most odd.
Devi
2008-09-17 12:49:30


I attended the Design Yatra for the first time this year, and as a student, I must say I enjoyed looking at all the works of designers from all over the world. Two of the most inspiring designers for me, were Eric Scott of Saffron and Tirso Francés of Dietwee. Rajesh Dhaiya of CoDesign was truly inspirational from among the Indian designer. His work was on a different level from the work presented by VCG and Elephant design. It was definitely fresh and taking Indian design in a new direction. Great work from all the other desingers too. It was also wonderful to have Harsh Purohit of Cognito talk about sustainability and how designers can invest their time in working on this highly pressing issue.

On the whole the Yatra was a great experience. I look forward to the next Design Yatra and hope to see some more Indian designers and perhaps even students with their portfolios.
Neeti Gokhalay
2008-09-17 13:52:49


A big shout out to Kyoorius for organizing this event.
It was the first time that I attended this event. There was lots to learn from all the speakers, and if I may, it served as a sneak peek into the professional world.

The variety of work that was showcased, and I believe the greatest learning a student of graphic design could take away from this is the realization that visual communication and graphic design is no way restricted to 2-d. In today's world, so much is visual and experiential!

I'm not sure about the Indian-ness of design as yet, though. It's still very early to be asking for an identity that strong, in a culture that is so heavily influenced by swiss-modernism, and design is relatively a baby. Globalisation and the emergence of new consumer sectors may also serve as a counter-culture to the purpose of "Indian Design". I guess only time can tell.

It was wonderful to have Harsh Purohit speak about sustainability. "The death of the metrosexual and the birth of the ecosexual." CoDesign's work was very inspiring as well. IMHO, VGC's presentation (visually, and maybe otherwise) kind of let me down.

But in all, this yatra has been truly inspirational, and is something that can raise the expectations and standards of students! Patrick- it's a beautifully penned summary for an enlightening three days!
Mahima Pushkarna
2008-09-18 17:36:47


Design Yatra, was no doubt a memorable experience, especially within the serene environment of sun, sand, soil and a little bit of rain in Goa, but perhaps time has come for the design community to be more responsive and focussed to a wider perspective. India witnessed terrorists attacks in its capital while another of its state was inching towards the brink of disaster, being hit by floods due to changing course of a river. What I want to convey is that, designers have perhaps a lot bigger responsibility other than developing brand identity and designing logos for companies meant for revenue generating. The talk by Harsh Purohit from Cognito definitely was some reliever but the need of the hour is that the speech shouldn't remain as an issue of discussion during the Gala dinner and then gets erased, but young designers should, actually, imply to those issues of sustainability and perform a duty that is expected from them , not only for the betterment of the human society but for the mother earth itself.
Abhishek C.
2008-09-18 17:51:45


The coverage of Design yatra was very nice , as a student of communication design it was tremendously inspirational... i got to see the work of many professionals of international repute and also meet them in person... especially interactive design ...which is still largely untapped in india ... meeting nic roope , eric kessels , jeroen van erp and paul belford would have been impossible otherwise ...
Hope to see a bigger better designyatra 09 .
Apurv Ray
2008-09-28 19:32:45


Does anyone here remember the name of the video, some speaker showed with those dudes jumping on a trampoline ?? There was also a man painting the progress bar at the bottom of the frame. If someone knows what i'm talking about. Please post a link here.
Alvito Falcon
2008-10-09 15:33:16


@Alvito
The speaker was me.
Here's the video
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=xfmJ6m97HqQ
CR Patrick Burgoyne
2008-10-09 15:40:00


Much to my dismay I was unable to attend the Designyatra. However, would be keen to watch any of the lectures, if anyone has any links to recordings of them please do post them up, I'm keen to watch them.

Thanks :)
Preeya Mistry
2008-10-09 22:47:09


Sustainability can it be sold as a marketing strategy?
Should it be presented as a profitable opportunity?
Doesn't that go against the intrinsic value of sustainability?

I felt a creepy irony and sarcasm seeing Harsh Purohit trying to sell the need for sustainable thinking. Can such
a sensitivity and paradigm be understood through a logical argument? His presentation was the outcome of a strategic tactic because the previous pleas and pledges and 'lets join hands' did not clearly work in the past few years which is why the questions mentioned above has
more meaning.

There were three P's .. they just didn't feel right
profit .. this word feels wrong on a slide with the word sustainable
protests - this will be the voice of people with true concerns, should the businessman forsee it?

But i am sure the speaker's concerns were genuine and the strategy he used to convince a blind emerging business community in India made logical sense.

The reversal was an integral part of the presentation where its no longer save our trees but save ourselves- i guess the human race will be selfish to the end of time.
bharath
2008-10-10 14:04:36


comment deleted by moderator
Iftekhar
2008-12-31 11:46:13


Tell us what you think

What happens with my feedback?

We no longer require you to register and have a password in order to comment, simply fill in the form below. All comments are moderated so you may experience a short delay before your comment appears. CR encourages comments to be short and to the point. As a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.

Share This — Social Bookmarking

Get the RSS Feed