Go Homo


Ad for the Gay Times’ Homo Promo campaign by Leo Burnett, Chicago

Right-wing conservative groups have often accused gay people of having an agenda to promote homosexuality. In response to this, the UK’s Gay Times decided to run an interesting recruitment campaign: selling homosexuality to the straight community. Editor Joseph Galliano explains why he asked five ad agencies to help promote the gay cause…

CR: In light of the recent campaigning in the US, did some of the usual arguments emerging from the far-right help as a starting point for the project?

JG: “Actually, it’s unfortunately much more historical than that. The idea that there’s this ‘homosexual agenda’ is something that has come up many times, over the last 20, 30 years. I find it hilarious, the very idea that gay people might have a coherent set of agendas.

“So I just thought that, if it were true and we were trying to and sell homosexuality, what would it look like? It’s a simple idea really. But the serious point is in highlighting just how ridiculous some of those kinds of attacks are and trying to answer them in a way that’s interesting and creative.”


By The King’s Arms Creative, Manchester

CR: How did the ad agencies you approached respond to this unusual brief?

JG: “Creatively, it was great how open the people were to a good idea. It was something that was simple and that tickled them. Almost all the agencies we approached took part, which was really good, especially as there was no money involved.”


By Isobel, London (detail shown)

JG: “It’s all amused us greatly and is a project that we’d like to turn into something real, maybe gettting a viral campaign going. There was a readers’ vote to decide a favourite and the ad that won was the Guy Minds Think Alike one by Saint. The creators of that one connected it up with a Facebook page, too. It’s a very sharp and focussed message.”


By Saint@RKCR/Y&R, London

“While there are many old fashioned ways of campaigning for a cause, we wanted to do something more modern and creative to get the point across, and not be completely humourless. So it’s an interesting step in that direction.”


By Iris, London (detail shown)

The campaign, along with interviews with the various creators of the ads, runs in the November issue of Gay Times which is out now.


By James & Joe, Leeds.

Full credits for the work featured here are as follows:

We Really Want You
Created by Leo Burnett, Chicago
Creatives: Reed Collins, Mark McGinnis and Bob Winters

Go Gay
Created by The King’s Arms Creative, Manchester
Creatives: Paul Watson and Lynton Hemsley

Because
Created by Isobel, London
Creatives: Richard Allsop and Jana Pejkovska

Guy Minds Think Alike
Created by Saint@RKCR/Y&R, London
Creatives: Paul Graham, Simon Labbett, Jeeves & Pete and Kris Saliba

GA Why
Created by Iris, London
Creatives: Neale Horrigan and Leigh Wallace

Anything She Can Do
Created by James & Joe, Leeds
Creatives: James Kiers and Joe Callahan

Comments...

James Nelson
07/Nov/08, 4:15 pm

Really like the James & Joe piece. pretty disturbing!

andy johnson
07/Nov/08, 7:31 pm

It’s an interesting idea, and I’m intrigued by some of the results.
Some seem very stereo typically gay, and as a straight man I don’t think that aspect would really effect my sexual persuasion. The mouth/vagina however is tempting me to spend tonight in Soho, looks so inviting, no really!!

Have these been distributed? With the public enjoying to complain at the moment (ref: Russell & Ross) I can’t see them lasting long. I’ll look out for them on Greek St tonight.

Paul M
07/Nov/08, 7:42 pm

not sure if this is really appropriate, whats wrong with heterosexuals just being heterosexuals??? if it were the other way round it would be banned in an instant - pretty shocking really

Ed H
07/Nov/08, 8:45 pm

strategically - guy minds think alike is really interesting. its the only one out of all of them that puts across a benefit really simply and succintly.

uri_s
08/Nov/08, 10:06 am

Is it really ok to try and get straight men to turn gay? I’m sure i remember it was highly frowned upon to attempt to turn homosexuals heterosexual!

Tom_Hal
09/Nov/08, 10:44 am

me thinks that was the whole point of this exercise perhaps. its weird when you look at it if it was the other way round. people would indeed by causing a real ruccus

sabine
09/Nov/08, 11:24 pm

Why is it, in the UK, that the term ‘gay’ often excludes women. Are there no ‘gay women’ in the UK then? What’s up wid that.

Michael [Boicozine]
10/Nov/08, 12:00 pm

its my impression from the article that this is an advertising experiment, not an actual recruitment drive by the gay community

this advertising does raise an interesting point, the age old question of nature or nurture

can someone’s sexuality be swayed by advertising? that should be the real question that should be discussed here not viewing this light humored advertising into gay propaganda

Luke Gallacher
10/Nov/08, 12:17 pm

looks like some people really missed the point of this one… as joseph galliano states: “the serious point is in highlighting just how ridiculous some of those kinds of attacks are and trying to answer them in a way that’s interesting and creative.”

those of you who read this article and still thought the point was to turn people gay, your reaction is precisely the problem that this campaign is trying to highlight!

plus, it isn’t as though heterosexuals haven’t tried to convert, or even ‘correct’ homosexuality through religious and psychotheraputic methods, not to mention the ongoing political and social bullying.

k
10/Nov/08, 12:50 pm

I’m sorry but the author appears to have made a mistake; this starts by saying “Right-wing conservative groups” and leads to “…the far-right help as a starting point for the project?”

There is a massive difference between ‘Right-wing’ and ‘Far Right’ just like ‘Left-wing’ and ‘Communist’, not all Conservatives hate Gay people or want to invade other countries.

I have worked at a few design practices and quite a few people believed in the free market and self determination and well as actually quite liking the idea of a United Kingdom, this doesn’t mean they are Nazi’s…

By the way, the posters are great!

Phil
10/Nov/08, 1:10 pm

i find it quite innappropriate even as an exercise to put on a show of ‘what ifs’ for this sensitive area… that is almost being ridiculed… imagine if this got out. the number of complaints it would receive

sam_walk
10/Nov/08, 5:47 pm

haha luv guy minds think alike.

arnoldw
10/Nov/08, 9:48 pm

controversial as it is it has seemed to have gone viral, must say something about it i guess. though i still question the moral direction

Ed H
10/Nov/08, 10:16 pm

I think this is a really brave and encouraging thing for GT Magazine run.

Nearly all of them have heaps more impact that the “Some people are gay, get over it” ads.

I’m also impressed these agencies had the guts to get involved, it’s brilliant to see such a male dominated industry embracing homosexuality.

Lisa Thistleweight
11/Nov/08, 1:17 pm

Hmm, so “go gay because women are disgusting”, “Go gay because gays don’t have kids”; the first insulting misogynist, the second just not true. Advertisers: give them a new idea to work on, and the same cliched claptrap comes out.

Kate
12/Nov/08, 2:48 pm

Do the “best” ad agencies in this country really have this little imagination? These ads rely heavily on stereotypes about gay men, which is pretty dehumanising. I see that gay women have whooshed straight out of the picture also.

JenniferRuth
12/Nov/08, 3:19 pm

It should perhaps be pointed out that Gay Times is a “gay men’s lifestyle and current affairs magazine” (gaytimes.co.uk) and so the project was specifically aimed at “recruiting” gay men

Mark
12/Nov/08, 3:44 pm

Hi. I think these adds are great.

>“go gay because women are disgusting”, - insulting misogynist

Believe it or not, I was brought up to think that men were disgusting. If uk.parents can pass that on to it’s boys, why can’t adults entertain the idea that some women are disgusting? Why is this such a “bad” thought?

>“Go gay because gays don’t have kids” - just not true.

Really? Two gays shag and some time later a kid just appears? Does this happen often? I’m sure a vagina *and* a penis needs to be involved. Ok, maybe you were talking about adoption. The advert wasn’t.

Gay Times: I salute you (but not like a sailor).

Lawtears <-straight, gsoh, etc

Lawtears
12/Nov/08, 7:24 pm

not only do i not like the ads… i find the whole idea of doing this as an ‘experiment’ totally innappropriate. has it got talked about yes… but if this were the other way round surely there would be streams of complaints and outrage!!?

barryb
13/Nov/08, 10:44 am

Wow. I love this article, and all that it stands for, either as an ‘experiment’, as it is here, or even if put into practice (hehe, this would be hilarious from any angle). This said I’m not 100% convinced that the stereotypicaly gay direction for some of the marketting does the job, even for the purpose of the ‘experiment’ here, as it gives the wrong message. All in all though, good job!

Dylan
13/Nov/08, 2:40 pm

Wow way to help out a repressed minority by hating on another repressed minority (women). Yes, go gay because women are disgusting. How vile can you get? Can you imagine if there was a poster with Blair, Brown and Prescott that said “go gay” and all the crap that would be aimed at it as “man hating”. But it is perfectly fine to portray women like this huh? Also the last one, so women are just a place to put a dick? I agree with the other commentators, have advertising agencies got so little imagination that they need to resort to this?

Shea
15/Nov/08, 12:47 pm

Post a comment

We no longer require you to register and have a password in order to comment, simply fill in the form below. All comments are moderated so you may experience a short delay before your comment appears. CR encourages comments to be short and to the point. As a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.

POST

Also from CR Blog...

Launch the Images of the Week Player
Subscribe to CR Blog

via RSSRSS Feed


Sponsored links

Code by Twelvenoon