The search for a voice

Designer Michael Johnson of johnson banks, looks back at his recent visit to India, where he found a design scene that is beginning to reflect the country’s unique and rich visual language…

Designer Michael Johnson of johnson banks, looks back at his recent visit to India, where he found a design scene that is beginning to reflect the country’s unique and rich visual language…

On my first ever trip to India, I managed to embarrass myself before I’d even landed. As the plane banked and approached the runway, I noticed multiple blue rectangles on the ground and thought ‘wow, that’s a lot of swimming pools’.

Those ‘pools’, I soon discovered, were the blue tarpaulin roofs of the slums by the airport, protection against the imminent monsoon. Before stepping off the plane I already felt like a colonial plonker, and shame has stopped me retelling the story until now.

(Pictured above: Shruthi Venkataraman’s ‘dipped in colour’ design for Kulture shop)

My tarp/pool story is typical of the experience of the firang (foreign) designer, flying in with his/her stock speech, clear views on everything from typeface choice, logo design and precious little knowledge of Indian culture and design, other than replayed sketches from ‘Goodness Gracious Me’.

On that first trip, I was bombarded with questions from students on how they could learn to design ‘more like me’. What they really meant was ‘how could they make their designs look more western?’ – I put that down to a kind of emerging market insecurity and assumed it wouldn’t be long before Indian design found its voice.

But it’s taken longer than I expected. Seven years after my tarp shame, I’ve just finished judging an Indian design scheme, and whilst there were many pieces that could and should hold their own in award schemes worldwide, much of the work could have been done, well, anywhere. None of the shortlisted work was in any of the local Indian languages, and only a small proportion seemed to pick up on vernacular design.

It seems, to a semi-outsider such as myself, that by looking West, Indian design has slightly lost its own identity, settling on something more mid-Atlantic instead.

Exacerbating the problem, the country now has its fair share of international consultancies working across the country or the region. Yet put much of the product of this work – from Airtel, to Apollo, to Tata DoCoMo and Pakistani telecoms brand Mobilink – on a powerpoint slide and there’s little or no sense of place. All we really see is a nod to international design trends, proof that design blogs are being studied slightly too closely and precious few attempts to lead, only to follow.

The paradox is that every firang designer, on those fleeting dashes from airport to podium and back again, is struck by India’s uniquely rich visual language. Not the outdoor advertising, which is almost universally awful, but the hand-painted walls, lorries and the indigenous craft tradition.

I’m not, of course, lobbying for every next Indian multinational to adopt logos based on truck type (although, wouldn’t that be something?) but it’s great to see that some of this is at least being recorded on site such as HandPaintedType.com – a tradition being curated, recorded and celebrated.

(From www.handpaintedtype.com)

(Also from www.handpaintedtype.com)

Of course there’s an inherent tension in pointing out the everyday vernacular in Indian cities. I understand why designers might want to run away from what’s around them, take a break from ‘Horn OK Please’…

(Horn Not Ok PLease design by Jas Charanjiva)

…look further afield and adopt a little more ‘Horn Not OK Please’. If every international company that rang us in London said “we really love that cute Underground map of yours and my cousin has a really great ‘Mind the gap’ t-shirt we want you to emulate” then yes, we might start to get a little tetchy too. Yet, I would argue, there’s no harm in accepting what’s there and turning it to your advantage, rather than endlessly attempting to be the next Vignelli or Olins, may they both rest in peace.

Thankfully, my most recent trip has given me the time and space to look a little harder and there’s clear evidence of a genuine design voice emerging.

(EK Painter Suhail)

(Ek Devanagari)

Take Ek Type‘s determination to navigate a well-kerned route through India’s multiple languages and supply consistent typographic solutions that can speak in a multitude of ways.

(Posters by Hanif Kureishi)

Or Hanif Kureishi‘s personal work (other than Hand Painted Type), such as his street art posters, using basic printing on newsprint, making no attempt to look slick, corporate or remotely western.

(Kohinoor Gujarati)

Indian Type Foundry‘s ‘Kohinoor’ typeface makes me wish I had an Indian client asking for Gujarati, just so I could use it.

Related to Kureishi is Kulture shop, providing an ever-changing window into the emerging graphic art of India, and is perhaps the closest glimpse yet into what’s to come.

With curated collections, artist collaborations and a genuine sense of India ‘now’ this feels like an early and successful attempt to pick up on India 21st graphic art – perhaps emulating British shows like Pick Me Up – but delivering in a markedly Mumbai manner, not Hoxton hipster. (And immaculately branded and packaged too).

Fast forward a decade and I can see Kulture shops in every major Indian city (and London, New York and Tokyo too).

With luck, soon WhiteCrow won’t have to supply local inflexions of international brands for very much longer, and simply do their own work. With more luck, the relaunched Royal Enfield brand will be just the first of series of ‘Made In India’ designs that triumph at home, then abroad.

In an ironic twist, when visiting Kulture shop I picked up a charming illustrated book by Sameer Kulavoor, dedicated to those ubiquitous blue tarpaulins and their ever-shifting role, from packaging and refugee camps to water-proofing the homes of the richest, and the poorest.

A piece simply celebrating this omnipresent material, and the multiple uses of it. A design happy to be honestly, uniquely Indian, not with one eye abroad.

And that, in my view, is exactly as it should be.

 

Michael Johnson, johnson banks, was in Pune and Mumbai doing a series of FYIdays for Kyoorius and chairing the second Kyoorius Design Awards.

This post was featured on the johnson banks ‘Throught for the Week’ blog at johnsonbanks.co.uk/thoughtfortheweek.

Follow johnson banks on twitter @johnsonbanks and on Facebook.

http://johnsonbanks.co.uk/

 

UPDATE – Here are some responses from Facebook so far…


You may also like

pathway388_0.jpg - The making of the Barrowland Park album pathway - 6660

The making of the Barrowland Park album pathway

Arranged like records on a shelf, artist Jim Lambie’s ‘album pathway’ in Glasgow lists the names and dates of thousands of bands that have played the city’s famous Barrowlands venue since 1983. Russ Coleman, the sculptor who worked on the Comedy Carpet in Blackpool, tells us how he turned his hand to coloured concrete

lewisbartlettimage1_0.jpg - Talent Spotters: Arts University Bournemouth - 6671

Talent Spotters: Arts University Bournemouth

As part of our Talent Spotters series of degree show reviews, Justin Barrow, art director and founder of Supreme design and branding agency, selects his favourite projects from the Arts University Bournemouth BA Visual Communication degree show…

studyinscarlet_0.jpg - Can you help solve a Sherlock Holmes mystery? - 6716

Can you help solve a Sherlock Holmes mystery?

George Pearson’s 1914 production of A Study in Scarlet was the first film to feature Sherlock Holmes – but it hasn’t been seen in generations. Now, the Museum of London and the BFI are hoping the public can help track it down, in time for the museum’s forthcoming exhibition on the much-loved detective

pentyale388_0.jpg - Is that your reversed-stress face? - 6711

Is that your reversed-stress face?

Since 1998, Pentagram’s Michael Bierut has been designing posters for the Yale School of Architecture’s series of lectures and exhibitions. The school’s autumn 2014 schedule has just been announced via this fine example, designed using the typeface Maelstrom

parragon_115x115

Packaging Designer

Parragon Books
pilbrowandpartners

Junior Graphic Designer

Pilbrow & Partners
gardenesque_115x115

Designer

Gardenesque
Hand3 copy

Photography Annual

Showcase your photography work to over a million people in more than 80 countries, across every segment of the creative industry.

Enter here