Creativity and programmatic advertising

Programmatic advertising offers the chance to connect with the right consumer at the right place and time. But it’s also been blamed for the rise of adblocking and increasing levels of resistance to online ads. Could a more creative approach benefit both brands and consumers?

If taking the lead on trends is part of your brand identity then it follows that Topman should offer up a crop of fresh ideas in its creative strategy as much as on its shopfloor. Last year Topman applied a creative programmatic strategy to the big fashion trend of khaki.

It shot the khaki look on five different models, each of whom matched to one of the brand’s five different customer ‘personas’, including ‘aspiring’ and ‘extreme fashionistas’. Tom Lancaster, senior creative manager at Topman, oversaw the development of these multiple creative executions, which then ran in parallel media placements online so that the most interacted with became optimised.

“Programmatic allows you to run segmented work that will appeal to all of your audiences – it then optimises the creative to the version that best suits a media channel’s audience.” comments Lancaster. “Taking the creative programmatic route gives you a much bigger brief and a lot more work to do but the benefit is that when you are building that creative you can make it the right kind of thing for each target audience.”

Programmatic advertising is gaining momentum now because of the attractive promise to brands of data-led real-time relevancy and accuracy in who they can target. With programmatic display advertising, Topman not only targets people on key demographics such as by age and job but has also found a relevant way to reach consumers on publisher and lifestyle sites beyond the usual fashion media.

However, although a creative programmatic strategy is a part of the ongoing picture for Topman, it has its limits. The first is the cost factor: “You have to think how much of your budget you want to spend on your creative versus your media buy,” explains Lancaster. “And obviously your media buy has got to be sizeable enough to want to spend money on all those additional creative executions.”

It is not only about the budgets for individual campaigns either: if a brand is taking a programmatic approach, it has to make sure it has a tailored experience to take them through to after they (hopefully) click on the ad. “If you capture someone with quite understated style but then take them to somewhere where there isn’t any of that available to them,” cautions Lancaster, “then you may have acquired someone but you might not be showing them something that converts them.”

Looking ahead, Lancaster sees a considerable untapped opportunity in the creative programmatic sphere. He would like to exploit the ability to embed live text with an advert, updating the copy for each type of customer and their lifestyle habits. He also sees the potential for serving different creative work in relation to the weather at a given IP address. “It is all the sort of things people have wanted to do for a really long time and if you had this granular level of media buying and creative production then you would do it,” says Lancaster. “However, the challenge is having all those options at the same quality level: getting that ‘hero creative’ finish lots and lots of times.”

The Your Style Sorted campaign featured a five model shoot showing different style personas and asked the viewer to take a quiz to see four trends for AW15 tailored to them
The Your Style Sorted campaign featured a five model shoot showing different style personas and asked the viewer to take a quiz to see four trends for AW15 tailored to them

Right Time, Right Place

While some fear the implied threat to creativity that the automated nature of programmatic brings, Nicolas Roope, co-founder and creative director at Poke, London sees it as timely. “It is newly available inventory coming together with concepts that already have personalisation and contextuality built in that makes programmatic exciting now,” comments Roope. “Programmatic is a natural extension of storytelling in the digital space: always about some degree of interaction, some degree of personalisation, some degree of contextuality and timeliness.”

With creative programmatic, those key principals of time, place and context can be applied at scale, giving mass reach to personalised advertising. Essentially, it allows brands to get more relevant and creative and Roope sees that creativity flourishing in the work of Unilever’s Axe brand in Brazil. The brand recently used programmatic adverts to serve online viewers with up to 100,000 variations of its Romeo Reboot ad. Those variations in soundtrack, setting and plotline were part of a personalisation that allowed for changes to six out of the eleven scenes in the spot. “Fundamentally, programmatic is interesting,” says Roope. “Because it highlights how limp, unintelligent advertising in a digital interactive space just doesn’t make any sense.”

If successful, he argues, it delivers compelling creative, connecting people with the brand at the opportune moment. Roope also cites Google’s work with billboards as a valuable example of an inspiring creative approach to programmatic. Google trialled its DoubleClick ad technology last year, allowing premium billboard ads to be bought programmatically and passers-by to see the most relevant adverts for the time of day and location. “The real time quality of weather, sports and travel news was quite a surprise and interesting for people,” comments Roope. “That contextuality can be really powerful.”

Affinity and Desire

The antagonism with programmatic tends to come when you examine the formats used in most programmatic deals, which are currently much more constraining than the formats used in broadcast media. Within creative programmatic, you need to have very quick, low-cost adaptability for the best campaigns to work. This may call for a hundred different versions of a very similar idea and so the construct tends to be more limited and more mechanical.

Programmatic has its place for Charles Vallance, co-founder and chairman of integrated agency VCCP, but it shouldn’t be at the expense of building a brand in full view. He argues that brand values and brand affinity are inextricably linked to bigger budget brand awareness campaigns. “We must value the advantages and efficiencies of programmatic,” he says. “But we must not have that at the expense of the colossal value of building a brand and building affinity that is shared and appreciated by a broader audience.

Vallance says that there are two things that communication can do: the short-term goal of selling things and the longer term one of creating an environment of ‘buyability’ around a brand. “If I only ever communicate to people with the precision of programmatic, I might never make them want to buy,” he cautions. “The two go hand in hand: you need broadcast or mass communication to create a collective sense of why this brand is desirable, what this brand means, what this brand stands for, and then programmatic can harness and exploit that.”

Shared real-time experiences will never go out of style and are arguably much more valuable than atomised, fragmented ones, however accurate they may be. “There is nothing very programmatic about Star Wars,” offers Vallance. “You don’t want 100 different versions: you want the one version that everyone is talking about.”

Charles Vallance, Tom Lancaster and Nicolas Roope will be speaking on a panel debate at Creative Review and Marketing Week’s Creative Programmatic event on March 2. The session will examine the opportunities and challenges of harnessing programmatic in the creative process. This article was first published on Marketing Week

More from CR

Welcome to Walter’s World…

Walter Iuzzolino gave up a successful career as a TV producer and creative director to set up foreign-language drama channel Walter Presents. With its shows now being watched by millions online and on Channel 4, we spoke to Iuzzolino about taking professional risks, uncovering great stories from around the world and how a growing appetite for international drama is creating new opportunities for directors, film-makers and producers.

Warren Richardson wins World Press Photo of the Year 2015

The award honours the skills and creativity of a photographer who has best represented an event or issue of great journalistic importance over the last 12 months, with this year’s winning image capturing refugees crossing the border from Serbia into Hungary at night

Exposure: Photographer Maisie Cousins

Art director Gem Fletcher examines the work of photographer Maisie Cousins, in the latest instalment of a series looking into new talent in photography, from recent graduates to photographers breaking into the industry…


NAO (National Audit Office)